top of page

A New Chapter on 44th and Penn

Oct 4
5 min read

Updated: Oct 18

Sandwich Club carries a family legacy forward

Grab a napkin. We’ve got a story to share, and this one comes with a whole lot of heart.


Photograph of the legendary Emily's F&M Family Restaurant in North Minneapolis

We’re working toward opening Sandwich Club in early November 2026 at 2124 44th Avenue North, in North Minneapolis’s Camden neighborhood. On the menu? Hot sandwiches, homemade soups, and our scrumdidilyumptious potato salad. If you know... you know.


But before we fire up the kitchen, we want to tell you about the people who made this next chapter possible—and why putting down roots here means so much to us.



Before our sandwiches, there was Emily’s–and then Pickles

In 1982, Emily Benincasa and her husband, Elliott, opened Emily’s F&M Family Restaurant. Think about everything that's changed between 1982 and today. I mean... they didn't even have internet when they started this!


Time passed. Generations grew up. Businesses came and went. The neighborhood evolved over time but Emily's remained a cornerstone. For more than three decades, their café served homestyle breakfasts and lunches in the Victory/Camden neighborhood.


When Emily and Elliott retired in 2019, their niece, Anna Donato-Ghani, and her husband, Gabby Ghani, stepped in to carry the family tradition forward.


For Anna, it was a homecoming. She’d started working at Emily’s as a high schooler. Years later, she returned as an owner, bringing decades of hospitality experience and a personal connection to the place. As North News reported, Anna and Gabby planned to keep the café running while also bringing Pickles Catering into the kitchen. Anna understood how much the restaurant mattered to the community.


Over the past few years, the space has mainly been home to their catering work. Through Pickles Catering and Mama Donato’s Woodfired Pizza, Anna and her family continued bringing people together around food, with their Italian roots and warm hospitality at the heart of it.


  • Sandwich Club owners chatting with Pickles owners
  • Marcus Brant looking at his new restaurant space on 44th and Penn

That chapter deserves its flowers, too. Anna and Gabby kept the family’s connection to this kitchen alive, and now they’re helping us begin our own.


We (Marcus and Kelsey) aren’t related to them by blood. But somewhere between the conversations and banter, the cleaning, and receiving the keys, this process began to feel like becoming part of the family. They’ve trusted us with a place that holds decades of memories, and we intend to take good care of it and continue building life-lasting memories.


A Studio Forty Two Production. Filmed & Edited by Rafi O'Ryan

While cleaning, we found little Emily’s stickers—small reminders of the restaurant’s earlier chapter. We plan to find ways to use those stickers and other keepsakes from that era in our new space. We want longtime customers to spot a familiar detail and smile, and new customers to discover whose footsteps we’re following.


A family legacy we’re honored to carry forward. From Emily and Elliott, to Anna and Gabby, to now us, Marcus and Kelsey: different chapters all connected by a love of feeding people.


The Northside deserves investment

North Minneapolis has faced serious barriers to accessing fresh, affordable groceries and is known as one of the nation's biggest food deserts. A 2025 City of Minneapolis report notes that, in 2017, North Minneapolis was one of the nation’s largest low-income, low-food-access areas. There has been little to 0 improvements for food accessibility since then.


The Federal Reserve Bank of Minneapolis has also documented how residential segregation and disinvestment have shaped the Northside’s food landscape—and how residents, growers, entrepreneurs, and community organizations have worked to improve it.


Those barriers matter and make a huge difference in the opportunities that exist for our community to access food.


A sandwich shop can’t solve grocery access on its own. What we can do is contribute another neighborhood food destination: a walkable place to eat, meet up, and support a locally owned business. Sandwich Club is here to be part of the community’s ongoing work to build a stronger local food scene here on the Northside.


North Market in North Minneapolis

North Market was part of our journey, too

Some of you got to know us during the summer (2025) at North Market. We loved that opportunity: serving hot sandwiches, meeting neighbors, and becoming part of people’s lunch plans. A pretty wonderful way to spend a summer, if you ask us.


But our time there was always temporary. When we wrapped up to return to serving the school we work with, we were still dreaming about a permanent neighborhood home for Sandwich Club.


Later, North Market announced that it would temporarily close beginning February 1, 2026, with plans to return as a reimagined community food hub. Knowing the place and the people who shopped there made that news especially sad for us. Interruptions like that matter in a neighborhood already facing barriers to grocery access.


We’re grateful North Market gave us a place to connect with you, and we’re rooting for its next chapter. Our time there also helped us understand how much we wanted a place where you could keep finding us—a familiar kitchen, a regular stop, and a home for all these sandwiches.


A year later, and we've found our home only a short distance from the North Market.


Getting here has taken some serious grit

Opening a restaurant has been exciting, exhausting, stressful, and occasionally all three before lunch.


Kelsey and Anna Donato-Ghani talking about the next steps for the restaurant space
Photographed by Kasey Robinson / Studio Forty Two

Finding private lending has been one of the hardest parts. In our experience, conversations about investing in a Northside restaurant have carried a lot of concern about perceived risk. Navigating that while trying to secure equipment and prepare a space has been tough.

Regardless, we move forward and onward.


The support from our community has been a game changer. You’ve shown up for sandwiches, shared our story, supported our fundraiser, and reminded us why we started. We believe wholeheartedly that we can build a successful restaurant here. Every show of support strengthens that belief.


We’re also excited to see Memoire’s opening in the former Tori 44 space nearby. More local places to gather and eat give neighbors more reasons to spend time along 44th. We’re cheering for a block where businesses help each other thrive and new life is given to this corner, creating a vibrant, flourishing community for all.


Marcus & Kelsey Brant, owners of Sandwich Club
Photographed by Kasey Robinson / Studio Forty Two

Help us turn these keys into open doors

Our grassroots fundraiser has a goal of $44,000, and reaching it would make an enormous difference in how we prepare this restaurant for you. Support the Sandwich Club fundraiser.


That support will help us transform the space, get the equipment we need, and build a welcoming place where we can serve you well. There’s a lot of practical work between having the keys and handing you a hot sandwich. Financial support is helping us bridge that distance.


The support so far has been tremendous. We've probably said thank you 100 times, but we'll say it another 100 times: Truly, thank you to all of our supporters.


Our fundraiser ends November 9, 2026, at midnight Central Time. We’re working toward opening our doors in early November, and we’ll share our confirmed opening date as soon as it’s ready.


Want to help us this grass-root, family-owned business? Become a Founding Club Member, make a contribution, or share our fundraiser with someone who loves neighborhood restaurants. And keep your eyes peeled: new exclusive merch is dropping soon!


We can’t wait to welcome familiar faces and meet new neighbors. To honor the family who came before us. To put our own love into this kitchen. And, finally, to get back to the very important business of feeding you.


Northside, save us a seat at the table. We’ll bring the sandwiches. 🥪

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page